FILED: March 8, 2000

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF OREGON

ALLIANCE FOR RESPONSIBLE LAND
USE IN DESCHUTES COUNTY,

Respondent,

v.

DESCHUTES COUNTY,

Petitioner,

and

STEVE SCOTT,

Petitioner.

(LUBA Nos. 99-027, 99-028; CA A108586)

Judicial Review from Land Use Board of Appeals.

Argued and submitted February 17, 2000.

Bruce W. White argued the cause and filed the brief for petitioner Deschutes County.

Robert S. Lovlien argued the cause and filed the brief for petitioner Steve Scott.

Charles Swindells argued the cause for respondent. On the brief was Thomas

Johnson.

Before Armstrong, Presiding Judge, and Deits, Chief Judge, and Brewer, Judge.

PER CURIAM

Affirmed.

PER CURIAM

Petitioners Deschutes County and Scott seek review of LUBA's remand of the county's decisions approving two applications to divide 40-acre parcels in an exclusive farm use (EFU) zone into smaller parcels and to place nonfarm dwellings on each of the new parcels. We affirm.

Petitioners recognize that the county's decisions are contrary to Dorvinen v. Crook County, 153 Or App 391, 957 P2d 180, rev den 327 Or 620 (1998), where we held that a materially identical county decision violated the requirement of ORS 215.780(1)(a) that, subject to exceptions that have no bearing here, the minimum lot or parcel size for county lands zoned EFU must be at least 80 acres. Petitioners contend, however, that Dorvinen was incorrectly decided and misconstrues ORS 215.780(1). Specifically, petitioners emphasize that this court's reading of the statute is inconsistent with local governments' understanding of and implementation of this statute before the Dorvinen decision, inconsistent with the intent of the legislature in adopting ORS 215.780, and is not sound land use policy. As we explained in Dorvinen, the problem with petitioners' arguments is that the text and context of this statute simply do not support petitioner's position. Accordingly, we adhere to our opinion in Dorvinen and agree with LUBA that the county erred in granting the applications.

Affirmed.


Top of page Go home

divider line

State of Oregon Seal